Duels Rankings Quiz

vs

StrikerDuel

Head to head striker comparisons built on curated career data. Made for settling arguments.

Explore

Duels
Rankings

Site

About
Data and methodology

© 2026 StrikerDuel

José Altafini vs Roy Makaay: career goals, stats and honours

Duels Rankings Quiz

vs

José Altafini

Italy

304goals·613apps·0.50goals/game

Roy Makaay

Netherlands

321goals·680apps·0.47goals/game

José Altafini

José Altafinivs Roy Makaay

Roy Makaay

Roy Makaay

Goals by age · club & country combined

Filter José Altafini +

Filter Roy Makaay +

1

International

0

x1

World Cup

5

Club

5

x1

Champions League

European Golden Shoe

x1

x4

Serie A

Bundesliga

x2

La Liga

x1

Pichichi Trophy

x1

Team trophies

DFB-Pokal

x2

Copa del Rey

x1

Supercopa de España

x2

x1

Coppa delle Alpi

DFB-Ligapokal

x1

KNVB Cup

x1

Individual

x2

Coppa Italia top goal scorer

x2

Golden Foot

ESM Team of the Year

x1

x1

European Cup top goalscorer

FIFA XI (Reserve)

x1

x1

Serie A top Goal-scorer

Other honours +

José Altafini

AC Milan Hall of Fame

More duels

?José Altafini vs ?
?Roy Makaay vs ?
José Altafini vs Pelé
Diego Maradona vs José Altafini
Cristiano Ronaldo vs José Altafini
Lionel Messi vs Roy Makaay
Cristiano Ronaldo vs Roy Makaay
Kylian Mbappé vs Roy Makaay

Where they rank

José Altafini#4World Cup
José Altafini#22Champions League
Roy Makaay#9Golden Shoe
Roy Makaay#11Bundesliga
All rankings

José Altafini updated 21 Jul 2026 · Wikipedia

Roy Makaay updated 18 Jul 2026 · Wikipedia